Skip to content

Internet Censorship In India Essays

Moviegoers in India were disappointed this month when producers of the critically acclaimed Hollywood film “The Girl With a Dragon Tattoo” cancelled the film’s release in India. The decision followed demands by the Indian Censor Board to cut scenes that were deemed “unsuitable for public viewing in their unadulterated form” – specifically scenes of torture and rape. Such censorship of films and TV shows isn’t new here, and Indian audiences have grown accustomed to random and often baffling cuts to even the most innocuous content. However, the recent surge in government censorship and regulation of different media – particularly, the internet and social media – has the Indian and international media buzzing.

Consider the following: In the last six months, the Indian government took 22 internet firms, including Google, Microsoft, Yahoo, Facebook and Twitter, to court over “objectionable content” posted by users online; lodged a formal complaint with the U.S government over remarks made by U.S TV host Jay Leno about a sacred temple in Amritsar; and raised a complaint with the producers of BBC’s show “Top Gear” for an episode that mocked “India’s culture and people.” And, it doesn’t end there. TV shows on English and Hindi language channels are increasingly facing the chop (literally) for “inappropriate” language or content.

Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month.

These incidents have sparked an intense public debate about the extent to which the government can (or should) determine what the Indian public gets to watch, read, or hear. Some have described this trend as the rise of a “nanny state” where media content is pre-approved for public consumption, while others have raised concerns about what this new regime of censorship means for the freedom of speech and expression. For example, the government’s crackdown on Google and others comes at a time when the internet and social media have become important conduits for the expression of people’s views and opinions. In August last year, social crusader Anna Hazare’s “India Against Corruption Movement” made headlines for its innovative use of social networking sites Facebook and Twitter to organize rallies and galvanize support for their campaign to create an independent anti-corruption agency or Jan Lok Pal in India.

Traditionally, censorship in India has been justified on the grounds of “cultural sensitivity” and the idea that Indian audiences need to be shielded from content that could offend their social, cultural and religious beliefs. Speaking to the media on the case against the internet companies, Telecoms and Information Communications Minister Kapil Sibal was quoted as saying: “We have to take care of the sensibilities of our people, we have to protect their sensibilities. Our cultural ethos is very important to us.” But as political commentator Pratap Bhanu Mehta points out, “cultural sensitivity is not a pre-given fact in India.” The reality is that India today is undergoing rapid social and economic changes.

More than 50 percent of India’s population is below the age of 25 and nearly 65 percent under the age of 35. There are an estimated 100 million internet users in the country, with the number estimated to triple by 2014. Mobile phone penetration, particularly in rural areas, is extensive with over 800 million subscribers in 2011. With the rapid expansion of well-paying jobs in sectors such as IT, software, and business-outsource processing, many young Indians have access to disposable incomes far greater than their parents and have aspirations to work and live abroad. Against this backdrop, the government’s efforts to censor the internet and other media is an anachronism and symptomatic of a pre-liberalization regime of state regulation and control that is long past. And let’s face it, in a country of 1.2 billion people monitoring or policing user content is simply not feasible.

As India positions itself as a global leader in the 21st century, one of its greatest strengths is its loud, boisterous, and often frenzied democracy. The right to freedom of speech and expression is a fundamental pillar of this democracy, and efforts at curbing this right through arbitrary laws and rules will only serve to turn back the clock on the country’s social and economic progress. Mahatma Gandhi once advised a newly independent India to pursue a path of spiritual and inner purity embodied in the principles: “See No Evil, Hear No Evil, Speak No Evil.” Surely a state that censors and curbs the free flow of information isn’t what he had in mind.

Mandakini Devasher Surie is The Asia Foundation’s program officer in India. She can be reached at [email protected] 

Internet Censorship: Censoring Freedom Essay

With today’s technology, communication and information can travel across the world in a matter of seconds. Ever since the internet was first made publically available in 1991 the ease of accessing entertainment, education, and information has been increasing every year. We now live in an age where roughly 30% of all people in the entire world are connected to the web ("World Internet Usage Statistics New and World Population Stats"). However, despite the obvious advantages of the internet’s freedom, some countries are trying to control the internet and display what it deems appropriate for the public eye. Many countries, including Australia, China, and North Korea implement a system to filter web content. Even the United States is now in debate to construct a system to filter the internet and remove sites that are considered censor-worthy. Although this may sound like a semi-logical approach to uphold our internet, countries that have this system abuse the censor for more than hiding adult content from children or removing drug paraphernalia sites. Chinese web content filters, for example, do not allow pro-democratic information, religious materials, and any speech considered improper. Another problem that also arises from the use of internet filters and blocks is that it is a direct violation of the freedom of speech granted by the constitution. Because of the many burdens and problems internet censorship brings, it is of great importance that we keep our American internet just like our country, free.
Internet censorship is nothing original for many people around the world. Several large countries around the world have been using this form of communication blocking to channel the actions of the internet away from what users wish to freely do. Since 1994, China has been looking for the best possible methods to steer users away from content they see unfit for the public eye. The Ministry of Public Security took the initial strides to strangle the freedom of online browsing when it issued its regulations regarding the use of the internet.
Individuals are prohibited from using the Internet to: harm national security; disclose state secrets; or injure the interests of the state or society. Users are prohibited from using the Internet to create, replicate, retrieve, or transmit information that incites resistance to the PRC Constitution, laws, or administrative regulations; promotes the overthrow of the government or socialist system; undermines national unification; distorts the truth, spreads rumors, or destroys social order; or provides sexually suggestive material or encourages gambling, violence, or murder. Users are prohibited from engaging in activities that harm the security of computer information networks and from using networks or changing network resources without prior approval ("International Debates”).
Several years later, in October 2001 Li Runsen, the technology director at the Ministry of Public Security, explained the new...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

Censorship of the Internet Essay

784 words - 3 pages BibliographyBruner, Ryan J. 'Why Decency.' Bruner Homepage. (1 November 1996). Yahoo Search.Cozic, Charles P. Ed. The Information Highway. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 1996.'Cyber-Liberties.' American Civil Liberties Union Home Page. (1 November 1996).Yahoo Search.Damschen, Gary. 'Speak Freely, Act Responsibly.' (1 November...

Internet Censorship and Technology Essay

1535 words - 6 pages Since its availability to consumers in the 90’s the internet has forever changed the way one can communicate with others. With improvements in technology and an increase of emerging countries the accessibility of the internet will only increase with time. Such a possibility is fraught with problems, problems that were later brought to light by the September 11 attacks. With widespread internet usage the means to do harm increases and for some...

Is Censorship Justifiable?

928 words - 4 pages The freedom to express is essential to the democratic way of life. Today, that freedom is under attack. Both private groups and public authorities everywhere are working to remove various forms of media; newspapers, films, music, and books from public reach, thus silencing these forms of expression. Liberalism is under attack when censorship is put into place, yet, it is understandable why these measures have to be put into place when...

Pros and Cons of Censorship: Controlling Media and Ideas

906 words - 4 pages Censorship, or what I like to call “controlled media”, is the control of ideas and content in our world. For as long as people have discovered that human beings have free will, there has been a way to regulate, govern and block the expression of its uses. There are many types of censorship when it comes to military, religion, political, public media or for just morale reasons. There have naturally been debates on whether censorship has truly been...

Internet Censorship

740 words - 3 pages Internet Censorship"And why could you not turn in your assignment, Michael?" inquired Mrs. Anderson after asking her 7th grade students to turn in their reports on the impact of HIV and AIDs. "I tried Mrs. Anderson," replied Michael "but the computers at home and in the libraries wouldn't let me find the information. All the sites I visited were...

Is censorship strong enough in today's media?

893 words - 4 pages Censorship is the control and supervision of ideas and information, which is supplied to society. It is necessary to have censorship for the protection of the family, the church and the state. All forms of communication media have to be censored for example: television, videos, cinema, books, radio programmes, news reports, tabloids, broadsheet papers and the Internet. In these modern times social attitudes have changed and censorship has...

Should the Internet be censored?

849 words - 3 pages Should the Internet be censored? From colonial times to the present, the media in America has been subject to censorship challenges and regulations. The Internet has become a vast sea of opportunity. Everyone is seizing the moment. The good and the bad of society have reduced the meaning of the Internet. Menace threatens each onlooker, as people browse the many pages of Cyberspace. As the new technological advances help to shape our society, one...

Internet Censorship

1596 words - 6 pages Everyone has heard of the Internet and how it is going to help set the world free. The Internet is the fastest growing form of communication and is becoming more and more common in the home. Companies these days do big business over the Internet, and online shopping has grown tremendously in the last few years. For instance, the online auction site eBay sells millions of items every year online. Many companies are making even more plans to...

Internet Censorship

927 words - 4 pages The Internet is a wonderful place of entertainment and education, but like all places used by millions of people, it has some murky corners people would prefer children not to explore. In the physical world, society as a whole wants to protect children, but there are no social or physical constraints to Internet surfing. The Internet Censorship Bill of 1995, also...

Censorship, Freedom or Suppression?

806 words - 3 pages CensorshipFreedom or Suppression ?Government censorship can be looked at as a blessing or an unneeded burden. I personally feel that all censorship is completely unnecessary and should be found unconstitutional. It is the countless moral views that bring no right answer for what should and should not be censored. I know that the governments version of...

Internet Censorship

798 words - 3 pages Internet Censorship "Internet Censorship." What does this mean to us? What is restricted? Censorship is summarily defined as the suppression of objectionable material. That means that material such as pornography, militant information, offensive language, anti-religion, and racism would be restricted in use. Freedom would not only be restricted to material placed on the web, but also what you could access, and where you could explore. Should...